Category Archives: Incident Analysis

Gun Grab Attempt Washington SRO Deputy

Every time a POlice officer is attacked in a gun grab, it’s a reminder that Open Carry is not necessarily a deterrent. It may be to a rational criminal but many folks are irrational.

Newly-released videos show the moments a suspected impaired driver grabbed a Thurston County Sheriff’s deputy’s gun during a fight at the scene of a car crash last month.

https://komonews.com/news/operation-crime-justice/body-dash-camera-thurston-county-video-sheriff-deputy-fights-with-dui-suspect-who-grabbed-gun-lacey-crime-public-safety-police-investigation

Items of note from the incident.

  1. The deputy’s openly carried firearm wasn’t a deterrent, it was an opportunity.
  2. The reason the deputy had to get into the fight of her life was because she was preventing the violent suspect from going toward the other parties who were involved in the crash. Don’t assume because you’re a rational person without malevolent intent that others you may have to become involved with are also rational.
  3. The suspect wasn’t a goof at personal combat, he was a Brown Belt in jujitsu.
  4. The taser had no effect on an adrenalized and pain resistant opponent.

Have a Happy Thanksgiving with your loved ones and be cautious when traveling to and from your gatherings. There will be plenty of drunk drivers about.

Lots of lessons from this incident. More about it on my Patreon page.

https://www.patreon.com/TacticalProfessor

Boyd’s Process In Application Not Theory

From a post on my personal Facebook page.

I avoid Stop and Robs in general. One of my men was murdered in one while working an evening part time. It scarred me forever. The hardest thing I ever had to do in the Army was sit with his mother while he was dying in the hospital and listen to her tell me how that POS had killed her son. It was heart breaking.

Many years ago, Evan Marshall, a long time Detroit policeman, wrote a column in Combat Handguns magazine. One month he described his plan if he was caught up in a convenience store robbery.

As long as all they’re doing is robbing the till (register), I’m going to act like a CPA from Akron and be a good witness. But if they start searching people, making people get down on their knees, or herding people into a back room, my wife knows to get away from me because I’m going to start shooting.

My soldier’s murder was captured on grainy surveillance video. He did everything the robbers wanted and opened the safe. They made him get down on his knees and then one of them shot him in the head. He survived for two weeks in hospital before he passed away.

When I went to visit him, his mother took me into an unoccupied waiting room and told me the story of what happened. I will never forget it as long as I live. Evan’s words came to mind and I decided then and there it would never happen to me.

This is Boyd’s Process; know ahead of time what your capabilities are and what you are going to do when the time comes. Then execute your plan without hesitation.

“He threatened me, and said he was gonna slice my head off, and that’s when I tried to call the police. He started throwing things at me, came behind the counter. I tried to run off, but he grabbed his hands around my neck, and pushed me out of the counter space, and that’s when I pulled out my gun and I shot him.”

https://okcfox.com/news/local/7-eleven-clerk-fired-after-shooting-attacker-in-self-defense

https://www.gofundme.com/f/support-stephanie-dilyard-after-job-loss?attribution_id=sl%3A4669c667-0958-49d4-a6a5-179769205986

The 1950 Assassination Attempt on President Truman

This post and article are dedicated to the memories and heroics of Officer Leslie Coffelt, who made the ultimate sacrifice, and Special Agent Floyd Boring, who kept his cool under fire.

In the afternoon of November 1, 1950, two Puerto Rican Nationalists made an assassination attempt on President Truman. It’s been described as the biggest gunfight in Secret Service history. Before the assassins were able to enter Truman’s temporary residence on Pennsylvania Avenue across from the White House, their attack was stopped by the White House Police and the Secret Service.

https://www.thetacticalwire.com/features/546e4b74-c821-4f5c-a59d-8ddbbb64aba7

It’s worth noting that the assassins were stopped by two shots by two men armed with revolvers, who knew how to shoot them well.

If you would like to read more in-depth information about shooting and personal protection, consider subscribing to my Patreon page.

https://www.patreon.com/TacticalProfessor

Another Mistaken Identity Shooting and Killing

Odds are that the ‘bump in the night,’ has no more than a 3% possibility of being an intruder. The other 97+% is either a family member, friend, or some harmless dumbass.

I calculated this based on information in the National Crime Victims Survey overlaid on several other authoritative sources. The analysis is slightly fuzzy but I stand by the general numbers.

CSU professor accidentally shot by roommate who mistook her for intruder

https://www.wtvm.com/2025/10/14/csu-professor-accidentally-shot-by-roommate-who-mistook-her-intruder/

[Muscogee County Coroner] Bryan said [Professor] Anderson’s roommate had been receiving terrorist threats from her son, including threats of bodily harm and to burn down the house. When the roommate heard a noise while sleeping, she grabbed her pistol and walked into the hallway.

‘She fired one shot and then fired another one and hit her roommate,’ Bryan said.

Calling out “WHO’S THERE” would save many a life. The concept that using a flashlight and/or issuing a verbal challenge will ‘draw the intruder’s fire’ is foolish and unsupportable.

Flashlight skills at home are important enough that I made the flashlight chapter of Indoor Range Practice Sessions a free download on my ebook store.

https://store.payloadz.com/go/?id=2505573

Note also that she was killed by one hit; this is not uncommon when a shooting victim is not highly adrenalized. Modern bullets are very lethal.

If you would like to read more in-depth information about shooting and personal protection, including making good decisions, consider subscribing to my Patreon page.

https://www.patreon.com/TacticalProfessor

ARMED CITIZEN – OCTOBER 2025

Anyone is free to quote or reproduce these accounts.

WalMart Mass Stabbing Foiled

On July 26, a homeless man in Traverse City, Mich., allegedly began attacking customers in a Walmart with no provocation. The man was reportedly armed with a folding knife and managed to quickly injure 11 people, some of whom were in their 70s and 80s, before a group of customers contained the assailant. A bystander’s video shows one of the customers, a retired U.S. Marine, drawing his gun and forcing the alleged assailant to drop his knife. The armed citizen then held the suspect at gunpoint until the police could respond. The hero later told reporters that he chose to try to de-escalate: “I didn’t think of anything other than trying to get him away from people and get him isolated and get him to put the knife down.” He also noted the bravery of the other men confronting the suspect, stating “the only thing that separated me from the other gentlemen … was what I was carrying.” The homeless man was being sought by law enforcement just before this event, though authorities did not specify why a warrant had been issued for his arrest. Additionally, he had previously been deemed mentally unfit to stand trial for grave-robbing charges and was instead committed to a psychiatric facility in 2016. The man now faces 11 counts of assault with intent to murder and one charge of terrorism. (abcnews.com, New York, N.Y., 7/28/25 and 7/29/25)

Authorities were searching for Walmart stabbing suspect prior to incident

https://abcnews.go.com/US/multiple-people-stabbed-walmart-traverse-city-michigan-suspect/story?id=124105185

Armed bystander who helped confront Walmart stabbing suspect speaks out

https://abcnews.go.com/US/walmart-stabbing-armed-bystander-interview-derrick-perry/story?id=124150799

Road Rage Defense

During the early morning hours of July 6, a man driving an Audi overtook a man driving a Prius and forced him off the road in Allentown, Pa. The Audi driver then exited his vehicle and began striking the Prius driver’s door with a metal baseball bat. The Prius driver was a licensed carrier and defended himself by shooting the assailant in the torso. The victim then drove a few blocks away and called police, and the suspect was pronounced dead a short time later. The incident was fortunately caught on security video, and the district attorney ruled the incident a self-defense case with no charges filed against the armed citizen. The Allentown mayor told reporters it was a “senseless” case and claimed it was a product of people “having too easy access to guns.” Reports did not indicate his opinion on the accessibility of metal baseball bats. (6abc.com, Philadelphia, Pa., 7/7/25 and 7/23/25)

Man killed in Allentown road rage shooting is believed to be the aggressor, investigators say

https://6abc.com/post/west-hamilton-street-road-rage-incident-leads-fatal-shooting-allentown/16986091/

Allentown road rage shooting determined to be self-defense, no charges to be filed

https://6abc.com/post/allentown-road-rage-shooting-determined-defense-no-charges-filed/17259858/

https://www.americas1stfreedom.org/content/the-armed-citizen-september-26-2025/

AI gets it wrong again

Grizzly Bear Attack

The grizzlies in Montana seem increasingly disgruntled. In the fifth such incident for the state, a man in Great Falls heard a disturbance with his chickens on the night of July 10 and left his residence to check on them. A grizzly bear was getting into the chicken coop, and reportedly charged the man, who shot it dead. Of the five reported incidents in Montana since April, this is the third involving a grizzly on someone’s property. (krtv.com, Great Falls, Mont., 7/17/25)

Grizzly bear shot after charging a man in Montana

https://www.krtv.com/news/montana-and-regional-news/grizzly-bear-shot-after-charging-a-man-in-montana

Warning Shot Foils Smash and Grab Robbery Attempt

On July 17, a mob of thieves attempted to rob a jewelry story in Anaheim, Calif. Security video shows about 20 people, several of them armed with pickaxes and sledgehammers, exiting four or five cars in the parking lot. They began smashing the store’s door, but the employees armed themselves, and the store owner fired a shot at one of the vandals, causing all of them to flee. The same store reportedly had been previously targeted as well, but the robbers were unable to get in, and another jewelry store nearby had been robbed after a vehicle was crashed through the storefront. The store owner bewilderingly attributed the robbery attempts to hunger. (foxla.com, Los Angeles, Calif., 7/20/25)

Anaheim jewelry store owner scares off mob of thieves by firing warning shot

https://www.foxla.com/news/anaheim-jewelry-store-owner-shoots-mob-thieves

Home Invasion by Multiple Intruders

On July 25, several armed men in masks broke into a home in Fort Worth, Texas, around 3 a.m. The resident shot at the intruders and then escaped through a window and called 911. Responding police found a wounded suspect one block away and transported him to the hospital. They indicated they believed the home invasion to be random, but the investigation was ongoing, and they were still seeking two other suspects. (wfaa.com, Dallas, Texas, 7/25/25)

Fort Worth man shoots home invasion suspect, escapes through a window, police say

https://www.wfaa.com/article/news/local/fort-worth-texas-shooting-home-invasion-robbery/287-6cccd5ac-88f5-443f-b4bb-f4883de40c1a

Home Invasion by Intoxicated Agitated Neighbor

A man was inside his home around 3 p.m. on July 27 in Forney, Texas, when an intoxicated neighbor approached the home “in an agitated state.” Several people tried to stop the man, but he reportedly forced his way through a glass door and began assaulting the homeowner. The homeowner, however, was armed and defended himself by shooting the suspect once in the stomach and once in the chest. The homeowner suffered minor injuries from the attack; the suspect was airlifted to a hospital and faces first-degree felony charges upon recovery. The investigation was ongoing at the time of reporting. (cbsnews.com, Fort Worth, Texas, 7/29/25)

Police say “ongoing neighbor dispute” led shooting of suspect in Forney

https://www.cbsnews.com/texas/news/forney-texas-neighbor-assault-concord-street-shooting-investigation/

https://www.americas1stfreedom.org/content/the-armed-citizen-september-26-2025/

               OCTOBER 2025  SHOOTINGILLUSTRATED.COM

Parking Lot Tactics

Greg Ellifritz recently wrote an excellent article about mitigating the risks we encounter every time we go into a parking lot.  https://www.activeresponsetraining.net/five-parking-lot-precautions  It’s great advice; much like my own protocols that I developed after LCDR Schaufelberger was assassinated in his car in El Salvador. https://thetacticalprofessor.net/2018/05/25/in-memoriam-albert-schaufelberger/

Two points in particular resonated with me. First,

Walk against traffic going to and from your car.  …  You may also be able to detect the driver distracted by texting or scrolling the internet on his phone before he runs you down as well.

Every time you go into a parking lot, you will see people who simply cannot put their cell phones down for ONE Minute between their cars and the store. As soon as they get out of the car, they start texting or talking, completely obvious to the two ton homicide machines moving all around them. When they leave the store, they continue blabbing even while they’re backing out of their parking space and driving down the lane.

The title of Colonel Rex Applegate’s most famous book Kill Or Be Killed comes to mind. Such people are ready and willing to kill you as they distractedly put their manslaughter machines in motion or they’re ready to be killed while yapping about something of no importance.

By walking against the traffic, you’ll have more chance to see the distracted driver before they run you down and then say “I’m so sorry” while you’re leaking and being loaded in the ambulance aka ‘amber lamps.’ https://youtu.be/53Bx5PLrOIk?si=zCk8BcJyDLOVFUS0&t=173 Note: in the first part of the video there “may be strong language used by those shown in the video. Viewer discretion is advised, especially for young children and sensitive viewers.”

The second point that resonated with me was:

If I do carry a shopping bag, I always carry it in my non-dominant hand.  I like to keep my gun hand free for a faster draw should I decide I want to respond with my weapon.

I disagree with Greg about this. My comment on his Patreon page  https://www.patreon.com/posts/five-parking-lot-138083166  was:

One point of difference. I carry the bag in my Primary Hand. During 10 years (around 400 iterations) as a role player in Force on Force scenarios, we never saw any clients drop something in their Support Hand when they were forced by the scenario into shooting. Even Rogers Advanced Level shooters would shoot Primary Hand Only. Same thing for less skilled shooters. That observation changed my mind about how to set myself up for success.

Parking lots are spaces in-between other places of relatively greater safety. Ramp up your level of awareness for two minutes when you drive into the parking lot and when you leave the store to exit the parking lot.

If you would like to read more in-depth information about shooting and personal protection, consider subscribing to my Patreon page.

https://www.patreon.com/TacticalProfessor

Man Shot by Deputy after Calling 911

#NegativeOutcome

After a Defensive Gun Use, don’t have your gun in hand when the POlice arrive.

[After the man called 911 saying he had killed someone,] The Ventura County Sheriff’s Office arrived at the man’s home in the 4300 block of Central Avenue in Camarillo around 12:30 p.m. on Thursday, July 31. The 79-year-old man was allegedly armed with a gun and the dispatcher, who was still on the line, had asked the elderly man to step out of the house.

The man was allegedly still armed and behaved in a ‘threatening matter,’ prompting one of the deputies to shoot him, according to the Ventura County Sheriff’s Office.

https://www.foxla.com/news/california-man-79-calls-911-say-he-killed-someone-gets-shot-deputy-home-officials

Most likely after a Defensive Gun Use, a person is going to be very excited. Plan ahead of time to put your gun down before exposing yourself to the POlice. In my first class with John Farnam, he advised us to say “You might want to look over there” and point to your gun that’s in a recognizable place. Probably best for it to be unloaded to preclude the possibility of an Unintentional Discharge.

This type of incident falls into the Negative Outcome category of Undesirable Police Involvement. https://store.payloadz.com/go/?id=2617872

I had a different idea for #fridayfundamentals today but not getting shot is definitely fundamental.

If you are interested in more in-depth commentary about shooting and Personal Protection incident analysis, please consider subscribing to my Patreon page. https://www.patreon.com/TacticalProfessor

Negative Outcome – Chasing and Shooting

https://abc13.com/post/spring-man-arrested-harris-county-constable-precinct-4-says-he-chased-down-shot-burglary-suspect/16052475/

“Constable Deputies have an adult male suspect in custody following a shooting in the 5400 block of Monteith Drive.
Investigation revealed that the male observed an unknown male breaking into his vehicle and discharged his firearm, causing no injuries.
The unknown male fled the scene and the vehicle owner chased after him for almost a block. Once he caught up to him he discharged his firearm multiple times, striking the male in the torso.”

I find the fact that the shooter was in camo interesting. Purely speculation on my part but if he was waiting in ambush for the car thief it will make the situation even worse.

It’s very galling to have someone steal your property but spending time in prison for reacting to the theft is even worse. Every situation we face has at least two alternatives; sometimes we have to pick the one that’s least worst.

The Good, the Bad, and the Ugly – October 2024

Whoops! I just realized that I had not posted the unlocked version of October’s The Good, the Bad, and the Ugly.

This month we have a Good story of taking care of oneself, a Bad story about failed parenting, and another Ugly story in which the authorities failed to protect someone they could and should have.
The musical selection for October is Metallica’s cover of The Ecstasy of Gold. Metal covers of songs from Westerns are rare and this is exceptionally good.

https://www.patreon.com/posts/good-bad-and-115130383

THE GOOD, THE BAD, AND THE UGLY – OCTOBER 2024

The Good

A Hubert woman who fatally shot her ex-boyfriend in self-defense earlier this month will not face charges, according to the Onslow County Sheriff’s Office

“the woman fired five shots from a .380 caliber handgun. He was struck by all five shots.”

The Bad

Baby shot and killed by toddler who got hold of loaded gun in parked car

The child who fired the shot was 3 and the victim was 10 months old.

The Ugly

A Minneapolis man has been charged with attempted murder after allegedly shooting his neighbor for pruning a tree he believed was on his property line, court documents show

This is a follow up on last month’s Ugly incident; bear in mind that it doesn’t take much to set some people off. Just as in last month’s incident, the authorities took no action against the shooter before the incident despite him having active warrants.

Enjoy!

If you like my work, join me on Patreon where I post more in-depth articles about shooting, marksmanship, and incident analysis.

https://www.patreon.com/TacticalProfessor

The GBU isn’t drawn from The Armed Citizen column of the official NRA Journals but the October edition of The Armed Citizen is attached. Rather than an obsessive interest in ‘the worst case scenario,’ it shows what the vast majority of Defensive Gun Uses really look like.

The Good, the Bad, and the Ugly – June 2024

Unsurprisingly, my hometown of Chicargo leads the post this month. Fortunately, the incidents fell in the Good category. Safety and mindset are fundamental in the other incidents.

https://www.patreon.com/posts/good-bad-and-107216506

The Good, the Bad, and the Ugly – June 2024

The Good – Shenanigans from Chicargo

Chicago concealed carry holder scares off armed carjackers in Irving Park

Bonus! The second happened a few blocks from the gas station (probably gone by now) where I worked after school in my Senior year. It wasn’t a great neighborhood then but apparently has gotten much worse now.

Chicago concealed carry holder shoots 3 men who attacked him in Belmont Cragin

The Bad

School District of Palm Beach County employee accidentally [shoots himself] during ‘training exercise.’

This story points out the importance of safe gunhandling at all times. Guns are relentlessly unforgiving of carelessness.

The Ugly

Minnesota dad told landlord he ‘already dug a hole’ before executing daughter’s boyfriend for suspected abuse

The number of people who feel that gunfire is the solution to most every problem astounds me. Many tools are only for a very specific task and guns are one of those tools.

Enjoy!

If you like my work, join me on Patreon where I post more in-depth articles about shooting, marksmanship, and incident analysis.

https://www.patreon.com/TacticalProfessor

The GBU isn’t drawn from The Armed Citizen column of the official NRA Journals but the June edition of The Armed Citizen is attached. Rather than an obsessive interest in ‘the worst case scenario,’ it shows what the vast majority of Defensive Gun Uses really look like.